One of the biggest decisions in a bathroom remodel is whether to install a walk-in shower or keep (or add) a bathtub. Both have advantages, and the right choice depends on your lifestyle, budget, and long-term plans.
Walk-In Shower: Pros & Cons
Pros - **Accessibility** — Ideal for aging in place; curbless designs eliminate trip hazards - **Space efficiency** — Can make a small bathroom feel larger - **Modern aesthetic** — Clean lines and frameless glass are trending - **Easy maintenance** — Fewer surfaces to clean than a tub surround
Cons - **No soaking option** — You lose the ability to take baths - **Resale consideration** — Homes with no bathtub may appeal to fewer buyers - **Cost** — Custom tile showers can be more expensive than a standard tub
Bathtub: Pros & Cons
Pros - **Versatility** — Great for families with young children - **Resale value** — Most real estate agents recommend keeping at least one tub - **Relaxation** — Nothing beats a hot bath after a long day - **Lower cost** — Standard alcove tubs are budget-friendly
Cons - **Space requirements** — Takes up more floor space - **Accessibility challenges** — High tub walls can be difficult for seniors - **Cleaning** — More surface area to maintain
What Sacramento Homeowners Should Consider
In our experience remodeling bathrooms across the Greater Sacramento Area, here's what we recommend:
- Keep at least one bathtub in the home for resale value
- Convert secondary bathrooms to walk-in showers for convenience
- Consider a curbless shower if you plan to age in place
- Budget $8,000-$15,000 for a quality shower conversion
- Budget $5,000-$10,000 for a tub replacement or upgrade
Our Recommendation
If you have two or more bathrooms, convert one to a walk-in shower and keep the other with a tub. This gives you the best of both worlds and maximizes your home's appeal.
